Signs & Wonders Camp

Zack —  June 15, 2012 — 15 Comments

 

 

So, if the people behind Jesus Camp are looking to make a sequel, I think we may have found their source material.

Introducing Signs & Wonders Camp. It’s brought to you by the people at the other IHOP. You know, the International House of Prayer.

Like any other church camp, this camp is full of frivolity, fun, games, and worship, but unlike most other children’s camps this one has an additional, shall we say “non-traditional”, element.

Campers will learn how to perform miracles.

Seriously.

As I watched this video for the first time, I thought for the first couple of minutes “Seems like a pretty generic, evangelical children’s camp.”

Then around the 2:00 min mark, things took a turn for the, um, interesting.

Apparently, after teaching the elementary school children how to perform miracles, the camp then brings in sick people from the community around the camp and has the children test out their new found healing powers on the strangers.

Now, I’m not saying that God can’t or doesn’t perform miracles. Of course God can do the miraculous and I think that God does indeed continue to perform the miraculous in all sorts of ways.

However, apart from the fact that I find the idea of turning a children’s camp into a training and proving ground for the “miraculous”, this sort of thing bothers me for several reasons.

For starters, it frustrates me to no end that whenever I cast my doubt on the miraculous claims I hear about cancer being cured or the crippled rediscovering the ability to walk after being touched by a traveling snake oil salesmen evangelist, I am then accused of “doubting” or “limiting” God.

I’m not.

My suspicion of people like Benny Hinn or even those behind this camp stems not from a lack of faith in God, but a serious lack of faith in those claiming to be able to perform the miraculous. Too often, they have been exposed as charlatans, taking advantage of and exploiting those in need for their own gain. Certainly there are those, perhaps like the people behind this camp, that aren’t exploiting the needy. But that doesn’t lessen my suspicions.

Furthermore, emotions and perception are powerful things. Sugar pills can heal if the people taking them believe they are actual medicine. Likewise, when emotions run high in a religious setting, our perception of what is happening can be easily and powerfully skewed. So, if I doubt, it is man that I doubt, not God.

Secondly, there is a fundamental problem in the premise of this camp and the contemporary Pentecostal approach to spritiual gifts.

The gifts of the Spirit are just that.

Gifts.

They are given to some and therefore by definition they cannot be taught, let alone be doled out with the price of admission at church camp.

Whatever spiritual gifts we are given can and should be developed, but there seems to this mentality among those behind camps like this that real Christianity or living a full Christian life requires a believer to demonstrate, not just spiritual gifts in general, but a handful of specific spiritual gifts, namely healing and tongue speaking.

That simply is not the case and, in fact, is something Paul himself would have been very much opposed to.

In the few places (and you can count them on one hand) that the apostle does speak about these sorts of miraculous gifts, he does does with great caution and trepidation, making sure to point out that all of us are given different gifts, none of us should strive to perform gifts we have not been given, and the greatest gift of the Spirit are not miracles or “secret prayer languages” (a notion found nowhere in scripture). The greatest gift of the Spirit is love and that gift doesn’t require paying admission to a training camp.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the contemporary charismatic movement too often, but certainly now always, puts the emphasis of the gospel in the wrong place.

Jesus did come, nor did he give us his Spirit, so that we could perform magic tricks.

Jesus came so that all of creation could be saved, redeemed, and reclaimed for the kingdom of God. Our participation in this divine drama is not found primarily in the expression of charismatic gifts. It’s found in our willingness to be God’s hands and feet in the world, through whom the love, grace, forgiveness, and compassion of Jesus are incarnated to a lost and dying world.

That is where the real miracles take place.

Not in the highly orchestrated confines of a “revival” service, but in the unexpected, everyday moments of life when we have the chance to transform lives in very much the same way that Jesus transformed ours.

If for you speaking in tongues and the laying on of hands are a critical part of that life, then fine. But as you do those things, please remember these words from Paul,

“If I speak in the tongues of men or of angels, but do not have love, I am only a resounding gong or a clanging cymbal. If I have the gift of prophecy and can fathom all
mysteries and all knowledge, and if I have a faith that can move mountains, but do not have love, I am nothing. If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing….But where there are prophecies, they will cease; where there are tongues, they will be stilled; where there is knowledge, it will pass away. For we know in part and we prophesy in part, but when completeness comes, what is in part disappears. When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me. For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known. And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.”

 

Grace and peace,

Zack Hunt

Zack

Posts

  • http://www.lifebeforethebucket.com Adrian W.

    As someone who is chronically ill (and only 22), this really frustrates me. If true healers are out there and can truly do this kind of stuff, why the heck haven’t I heard about it? Where do they get off on training children to heal something I’ve been working and praying to heal for 22 years?

  • Abby Normal

    So, if they were to take away the Jesusy stuff and call them “spells” instead of “miracles”, what would be the difference between witchcraft and this malarkey?

    I find it kind of ironic that folks that are known for throwing a hairy fit at the mere mention of a certain Mr. Potter think that it’s totally cool to teach kids to do magic tricks as long as enough Christian-y trappings are thrown in.

    • http://www.patheos.com/blogs/unreasonablefaith/ VorJack

      So, if they were to take away the Jesusy stuff and call them “spells” instead of “miracles”, what would be the difference between witchcraft and this malarkey?

      There’s an old rule, going back at least as far as the Romans:

      If I do it, it’s a miracle. If you do it, it’s magic.

  • http://notes-from-off-center.com Andrew Tatusko

    Oh my. Religion based on pure emotion is why we have people dropping out of religion when they hit a point in life where they just don’t feel so hot anymore. Emotions connect with reality but aren’t the content of reality.

    • Zack

      “Emotions connect with reality but aren’t the content of reality.”

      Amen.

  • Mark

    “Why won’t God heal amputees?”

    • Karen

      Luke 22:50-51. Who says God doesn’t heal amputees?

      • http://personman.com Danny

        “Who says God doesn’t heal amputees?” Uh, how about all the present-day amputees? They’d probably say that God hasn’t healed them, right? It’s one thing to point to a story in a book, but do you have any evidence that an amputee has been healed in the last 300 years?

        • Karen

          Me, personally, no, and I would expect it to be well out of the norm, but even medical science is now figuring out how to regrow body parts from a person’s own stem cells. Why wouldn’t the God of the universe be able to do that if He were so inclined and in the right circumstances? On principle alone (either God can do miracles or He can’t), I do not doubt that any sort of miracle that is consistent with the way I see God working in the stories in the Bible could happen, and I don’t have to personally witness one to believe the witness of someone else.

  • kim

    What you posted was the 2010 promo vidoe. It was emailed to me by one of the parents from my old church as a summer option for the kids. The 2012 video is pretty much the same thing.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtY4BhHJ-Po

    I took major issue with this back in 2010 when I was still a Christian and a leader in my churces Children and Youth Ministries. The very t-shirts they used showing a person rising from a wheelchair after prayer was enough for me to be against sending my kids there. To give children such false hope. To teach them about miracles and healing like that made me physically ill. What do you say to them when they pray for a friend or relative away from camp who never gets better? I know all the things we like to say about God’s plans etc, but these young minds process things differently. They’ll perceive it as a failure that can have devastating effects on their well being.

    We are to protect children from things like this, yet if it’s done in the name of God, we allow it. I remember looking at a boy in my youth group who had been in a wheelchair for 2 years after an accident and thinking I would never let him see this promo video. I would not expose him to such a terrible bastardization of scripture and human abilities.

    I was adamantly against it when I was a Christian charged with teaching children. Now that I no longer believe in God, I find that I’m still equally outraged.

  • Greg D

    Very well said, Zack. Yes,I too believe in miracles. But, up until recently I was a skeptic, ascribing to the belief that the gifts of the Holy Spirit ceased at the end of the apostolic age. However, it was when I went on to the mission field that I became a new believer of miracles, gifts, and wonders. And, after witnessing a couple of remarkable miracles, I was still a skeptic until a missionary told me that these things occur all the time amongst the poor and the destitute. I believe miracles, signs, and wonders occur more often amongst the less fortunate and amongst people who have never heard the Gospel or seen the love of Christ. I think it’s more difficult to see the true move of the Holy Spirit amongst rich, privileged white kids in the most wealthiest nation in the world where they can go home to their upper scale homes in suburbia America where Mom and Dad are sporting their new cars and latest electronic toys. But, these kids that live in trash dumps, rummaging through garbage in Honduras, or the Roma kids here in Albania who might not have something to eat for a couple of days… I see the Spirit at work.

  • Karen

    Kim, my heart goes out to you. I have friends who were deeply damaged by this kind of false approach to “signs and wonders” for exactly the reason you describe. Unfortunately, the nonsense in this video is what happens when people take the Bible’s teaching out of its proper context (from my perspective, that’s the Eastern Orthodox Church). They do not understand Church history and the spirituality and wisdom of the true Apostolic, Catholic and Orthodox Christian faith. Very few Protestants, let alone Pentecostals, are taught anything about Church history (or at best, get a very skewed angle on it), the development of Christian doctrine, or the spirituality of the saints and fathers of the Church. In other words, to some extent and in varying ways, they do not understand Christ’s work and the Scriptures of the Church in the way the writers and recipients of the NT did (and Eastern Orthodox still do). If you were to begin an exploration into this, you might find out that what you thought was Christian faith was only a poor caricature of the real thing.

    I don’t know what “God” you now don’t believe in, but chances are it is not the same One the Eastern Orthodox Church knows and has been proclaiming for 2000 years (though there may be some superficial resemblances)! Scripture invites us to “Taste and see that the Lord is good.” If what you experienced was not good, you can be sure it wasn’t of the Lord either!

  • alldayeveryday

    - I imagine that having children put their hands on you and tell you that they love you and that a god loves you and that they both want you to feel better would feel wonderful! I can see how attractive it would be to feel like this power was at your command…… but, you know, like Stevie said: “When you believe in things that you don’t understand “

  • Paul D.

    Anyone who thinks faith healing is real needs to read The Faith Healers by James Randi.

  • Pingback: Signs and Wonders Camp